Blog
Monet, Mitchell & Me Chapter 8 "Nothing Held Back"

Note: I'm a day late posting this due to presentation of MM&Me at the Benzie Shores District Library yesterday. Very nice turnout and, after some technical challenges, it was a profound and fun time. I pitched the book version for the first time and there's lots of interest. Yay! Enjoy .... Ellie
Today we’re leaving Claire Seine. Our plan is to stop in Rouen before heading to Etretat on the Normandy coast. In Rouen we’ll look at the cathedral Monet painted and see what else we can see in a couple of hours. Rick Steve’s has a list of tourist options to choose from, including a café we might try.
Before we pack up to go, however, I once again set up my outdoor studio and make some small sketches. I've vowed won’t make the mistake of neglecting my art practice again. No longer under the influence of either Mitchell or Monet, I’m not thinking about what to paint—I just start making marks. A few bird shapes land on my small rectangles. Some vertical marks that could be trees. Or not. I enjoy using the ink sticks and then layering gouache on top and play with switching brushes, to make watery marks and fine dry lines. I love mixing the colors—rosy pinks, sherbet greens, periwinkle and aqua blues, a nice pile of mango—and laying them on the thick bright white paper.
I’m pleased with my growing pile of paintings but am now concerned I’ve not brought enough paper to keep painting at this rate—I’ll want to find an art supply shop soon! —but it’s no use worrying now. It’s time to get on the road and, once again, we program Fifi to direct us. (The question of whether we can trust Fifi to get us where we want to go has been resolved with some Googling last evening. We discover there is no longer a Porte-Joie. Fifi apparently hadn’t gotten the word that Porte-Joie and another village, Tournedos-sur-Seine, had merged into one commune, Porte-de-Seine.) For the first time since leaving Paris, we let Fifi take us onto a major highway and before an hour has passed, we arrive in the city of Rouen.
It's Saturday and the city center bustles with locals and tourists at a colorful food and craft market. We wander through looking for the Cathedral and, sure enough, following the crowds, we find it. A plaque marks the spot where Monet stood to paint the cathedral’s façade at different times of day and under varying light conditions. When it comes to plaques, tributes to Monet are only slightly fewer than war memorials found all over France. Some clearly consider it heroic that Monet made more than 30 paintings of the same subject from the same spot; however, it wasn’t heroism—he was obsessed and simply doing what an artist must do—paint with a passion!
Passion for, or obsession with a motif, or a method, is the way of many artists. I and thousands of other outdoor painters have also trundled with my painting gear to a particular site to paint day after day. Wrestling with a subject is like wrestling with an angel—you do it until you can’t do it anymore and then, hopefully, it gives you a blessing—relief from your obsession. Claude Monet paints his wife on her death bed. Later on, he spends huge amounts of money creating a water lily garden pond that he then paints for the last 20 years of his life and won’t give them up. Joan Mitchell, another obsessive type, chain smokes herself to death while producing one brilliant monumental canvas after another, staying up through the night listening to loud operatic music sung by Maria Callas, doing the thing she is driven to do.
When I first started painting, at age 52, I was hooked; I stopped watching television to paint in the evening as well as during the day. Trips to the grocery store were to buy fresh pears to paint, not supper for the table (though occasionally overripe pears ended up in a dessert tart). I was entranced by what seemed the magic of paint to translate those pears into a picture that could hang on a wall. Within six months I’d made 65 paintings and displayed them in a first home show for friends and family. I was off and running on a third career that continues today.
Artists, like Monet, Mitchell, and me, tend to have intense personal engagement with their art. But many abstract artists— Monet eventually joined our ranks—seem particularly so, due in large part to the shift from outer referencing to inner. While an obsessive outer-referenced painter might chase better materials and technique to perfect the ability to create better and better copies, the passionate inner-referenced artist searches for a miraculous je ne sais quoi within the never-ending Rorschach of each of his or her paintings.
I now understand my strange attraction to and preference for abstract art—it’s somehow more real to me than representational art. The beauty, truth and goodness in a painting is no longer out there in the world, but here, as the artist paints from the inside out. It’s a more real world than the one I perceive with my five senses and much more challenging to express. One has to sneak up on one’s inner reality with spontaneous rather than measured mark-making, restraining the right hand from second-guessing what the left hand is doing. Paint-to-please presents an irresistible temptation, but occasionally something interesting and beautiful happens that not been mediated by the insatiable approval-seeking ego. The making of abstract art not only has the capacity for transcendence but also for transformation of both maker and viewer. This requires immersive engagement, however; what I’d been hoping for and did not find at the Orangerie and Fondation Louis Vuitton.
We leave the subject of Monet’s obsession to other tourists and find the place Rick Steves suggests. As it's the height of lunch hour, we’re fortunate to have to wait only ten minutes for a table; once inside I enjoy a kir royale and, while we wait another hour for our food, it’s a pleasure to watch as whole families take their time over Saturday lunch. After our savory galettes we opt for dessert crêpes swimming in hot fudge, custard, and whipped cream and, without a thought for sleeping later tonight, I have a coffee too.
We’ve stayed in the cafe for over two hours and now we have only a short time left on our parking meter. On our way to the car, we see another massive Gothic church, the Abbey for the Saint-Ouen Abbey, and we duck inside for a quick look. Hardly anyone is there, although someone is playing an organ and the bass notes reverberate throughout the sanctuary. Curious, we venture closer, stopping where an iron filigreed screen appears to block entry. We hesitate because a man in a rumpled gray raincoat, comes up and speaks to us. Roo has difficulty understanding him. He unshaven and missing some teeth. Is he a homeless person like others we’ve seen around churches in France? Is he asking for money? Apparently not, because he opens a gate and waves us to come forward into the chancel.
Unsure whether we’re actually allowed here, we follow him, thrilled to get closer to the action. Even here we can only barely see over the huge console the woman who is working the keys and pedals; the sound she is producing is so richly sublime it doesn’t matter. We’re so enjoying how the sun shines through the large stained glass and lights up the vaulted ceilings. It seems remarkable that we have stumbled upon a rehearsal—if that’s what this is—such that we hardly notice the scruffy man now reaching into a battered case sitting on a bench at the base of the organ. Putting a trumpet to his lips, he begins sounding clarion-clear notes in concert with the organ. It's hard to tell if he's improvising or playing from memory because the music sounds almost jazz-like. I’m struck by the simplicity of his soulful expression—for the moments we listen, he holds nothing back, it seems. How timely that we happened upon this scene, that we were welcomed to partake of this unexpected artistic communion.
The musical interlude concluded, we locate our vehicle and drive around downtown Rouen in search of an art supply store. Surely there must be one here somewhere, but we come up short. I hope to find one in Etretat where Fifi seems to know the way, first along a highway, then along some twisty lanes that lead down at last to the seaside village.
***
I was once only interested in how well a painter could accurately represent a subject. Like those who couldn’t understand why Monet created paintings that looked blurry and unrealistic, I was looking for a certain kind of talent in artists, the kind that has mostly to do with eye-hand coordination, that allows one to copy. I voted with those who looked askance at modern abstraction because it resembled a child’s kindergarten scribbles.
When I first began painting, I also wanted to copy: success meant showing myself (and others) that I could render a pear in paint that looked like a pear. Later, as a landscape painter, I wanted my scenes to be recognizable, accurate in their representation. Teaching myself, I looked at a lot of landscape by other artists. Several large books of Impressionist paintings, including several exclusively devoted to Monet, came into my hands and I spent hours poring over these, looking for clues as to composition and rendering. Unlike those who first resisted Impressionism, my eyes were accustomed to seeing these interpretive paintings. I’d grown up seeing poster prints of "Woman with Parasol” in variety stores and gracing the walls of college dorm rooms. I liked soft edges and light effects.
Although I admired Impressionist painting and Monet “coached” me through my early attempts at landscape, my own, quite different, style emerged almost immediately. Early on, a painter friend compared my paintings to those of Derain and dubbed me a Fauvist. A gallerist saw a similarity to Wolf Kahn and called me a “kickass colorist.” Pleased to have those more learned than myself draw these comparisons, I was less interested in my style than I was in simply making paintings on site, en plein air just like Monet under the tutelage of Eugene Boudin.
I found a teacher and tentatively asked him for help. R. A. (Alec) Moseley, a student of Don Stone (in the lineage of John F. Carlson and Emil Gruppe), took me under his wing in Vieques, Puerto Rico. On the beach at Sun Bay one afternoon, Alec showed me how the compose an outdoor painting by first making a thumbnail value sketch Sun Bay, then applying pigment mixed from a limited "Impressionist" palette to create a scene of coconut palms in the late afternoon sun. After a couple of outdoor painting lessons, he set me free with the simple instruction to “keep painting.” I painted like a fiend on this tropical island for the better part of six months, up and out early in the day and, again, at the golden hour just before sunset. Back home in Georgia, I continued to paint outdoors and, although I was not inspired by the humid, closed atmosphere in the sprawling suburbs of Atlanta, I did keep painting.
Then, after years of contending with traffic, pollution, and other effects of rampant population growth, we happened to visit a friend in northern Michigan. Lake Michigan and the dune land along the coast presented a unique mix of landscape features: water the color of the Caribbean, sandy beaches, deciduous forests on the dunes, farmland with iconic barns. “I could paint here for the rest of my life,” I declared, and the landscape painter in me meant this very sincerely. A residency at the Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore and a series of serendipitous painting adventures led to the purchase and renovation of a Victorian fixer-upper in Frankfort, a town with 1500 year-round residents, and the opening of my Studio & Gallery.
The practicalities of showing and selling my paintings during the busy summer season meant less time to paint outdoors. My painting expanded from small plein air panels to larger stretched canvases. I became interested in simplifying shapes and pushing colors and, without realizing it was happening, I transitioned from realism to abstraction. While I was painting from reference photos I’d taken in the nearby countryside, I used them more as a place of departure for a different sort of semi-abstracted landscape.painting. My fresh treatment of beloved “Up North” features brought to my gallery collectors eager to purchase my work.
Working in the studio also allowed me the freedom to explore new ways to approach painting. Loud music, which I’d employed in my work as a spiritual teacher to help people let go (“Let the song sing you,” my own teacher Richard Moss had suggested), now served to facilitate my own release from limited notions of what a painting might be. I might begin a painting session by listening to the Rolling Stone’s Greatest Hits album, phasing into an operatic aria, and later, some gypsy jazz. I used non-traditional tools, including my hands, to apply paint.
Occasionally, I’d listen to NPR and paint in response to the news. In 2013 I painted while following the tense drama of the Marathon Bombing. My sister lived in Cambridge, next to the neighborhood where the bomber was found hiding, and has been told to shelter in place. I knew the area well and, in fact, many years before, in the same part of Cambridge, I’d been arrested in a political protest and jailed in the same place the bomber was eventually taken. The mix of my history with these current events made the colors on my brush come alive on what emerged as a very strong painting of an abstracted barn.
Political events in 2016 led me to abandon realism almost completely. Fear and anger over the election of Donald Trump seemed to call for something stronger than the colors of the Impressionist palette I’d used since first adopting it from Alec Moseley. Black was not among those colors, but it seemed most appropriate for giving expression to my emotions. I found myself splattering black splotches on large canvases or squeezing it directly from the tube, as I’d seen in a Jackson Pollock bio pic. Black shapes, random marks I'd fairly throw on the white canvas surface, were satisfying to make. Like a signature, they seemed uniquely mine. In time, these gestural strokes assumed the character of non-specific birds. No stranger to mystical meanings, I marveled as birds flocked to my canvases; I began to regard them as intuitive messengers of hope and healing, convinced they had a mission to accomplish for our troubled world.
In 2017 I traveled to North Carolina to see an exhibit “Women of Abstract Expressionism.” Among the more than dozen women represented there was Joan Mitchell (listed 4th in the list of well-known artists). The show brochure advertised “large-scale, colorful, and energy-filled canvases … certain to thrill and inspire museum visitors.” I was inspired by the wide range of expression on display. Bright, dark, pretty, ugly—the work of each artist seemed to give me permission to say whatever needed saying. I came away from the show emboldened to make my marks in the world. I had enjoyed seeing Joan Mitchell’s paintings in person and, when I brought home the exhibition catalog, it was her paintings I found myself drooling over.
I spent the next 4 years devoted to creating and producing the large multimedia installation BIRDS FLY IN: A Human Refuge. (I was flattered when several people looking at my large avian-themed paintings remarked that they reminded them of Joan Mitchell.) After its two exhibitions in Michigan, I spent another year and a half making proposals and following up leads for subsequent exhibits. So far, these efforts have not proved fruitful. Still, I continue to paint uncertain if what I’m producing now will ever live up to work created for the installation project. And wondering why, if BIRDS is my masterwork, it hasn’t made the impact I’d felt certain it would.
This pilgrimage to France, however, is giving me some perspective. For one thing, it’s taken on the flavor of a vision quest. I’ve not only been looking for clues to my life as an artist, but I’ve also been finding a few. Unexpected experiences in three different churches—given my complicated history with churches, they are not my favorite places—have opened my heart to an awareness of the power of art and an appreciation of those who make it. The trumpeter in the Rouen Abbey, in particular, has reminded me of how simple it can be to claim a space in the world for an authentic artistic expression—just blow that horn! Do the art that is yours to do! Do your art and keep doing it!
Art worl giants like Monet and Mitchell lived large in their art. To an onlooker they appear obsessed. Do you really need to paint 30 versions of the same cathedral façade, Claude? Joan, must those canvases stretch to the ceiling and do you have to smoke heavily and booze while painting them? An artist’s total immersion in art-making makes us intense personalities, overly sensitive and often isolated from others. So, yes, says Monet, I will paint the church as many times as it takes. And, yes, says Joan, I’ll make these paintings if it kills me. I have a purpose and a passion to fulfill it. What’s inside of me, I commit to let out.
In me the passion for art is a longing to connect with and give expression to something deep and essential within. This something individual to the artist, but if the expression comes from deep enough, it also seems to tap into the collective unconscious and resonate widely with viewers. Most artists begin with notions of what it means to make a good painting, considerations of talent, art education, etc; yet, if they develop, he or she comes to realize that all the paintings that come off the easel are to a greater or lesser extent about the artist, not the subject.The measure of artist’s success is not her ability to make something appear real, or “good,” but her capacity to understand what of herself she has allowed to be revealed of what’s inside her.
Henri Matisse once said, “I paint in order to understand myself.” I laughingly tell people I've realized it really is all about me! What does Monet learn about himself when he cannot resist painting his wife’s corpse. As creepy as this seemed to me at first, I admire his courage for not succumbing to what might be universally judged inappropriate. And, when it comes to Joan Mitchell’s drinking and smoking , indulging in bad habits or vices seems to have given many artists the Dutch courage necessary to go deeper by removing inhibitions. I don’t smoke or drink excessively but I do engage in spiritual practices such as meditation that are known for opening intuitive channels. When I paint from the inside-out, I rely on intuition to guide my apparently random choices.
To open the "doors of perception," Aldous Huxley’s term for the way to higher/deeper states of consciousness, requires penetrating the many layers of personality that would block them. Art-making reveals first one, then another, and another, false self until one day, a true work of art spontaneously emerges. When this un-self-conscious creation occurs, it feels like something magical has happened. “I” didn’t make that painting, it made itself. It was effortless, took no time at all. The paint jumped onto the brush. As a public speaker I’d had the powerful experience of setting aside notes and speaking to a large audience from my heart. Listeners lined up for 2 hours to tell me how the words I’d spoken were exactly what each had needed to hear. I've learned that, in a similar fashion, art that moves people deeply is also created by setting aside the self and letting a larger Self choose the paint and move it around on the canvas.
All artists attempt to do good work, but many don’t have a clue what that means. We want to make a “good” picture, one, likely, that will please ourselves and, hopefully, entice others to take it home. However, I’ve come to realize the true goodness an artist is aiming for it is not found in the picture-product but in the process of translating oneself more and more accurately, that is, authentically, with paint. The impulse to make art arises from within and, for those who consent, it’s irresistible, compelling, and at times, fearsome, as it takes an artist to edges of his or her known world and demands surrender to Something More. An artist’s ego serves the art impulse to the extent that it puts aside distracting concepts and lets it rip. In the absence of a service orientation, an artist’s ego will likely settle for playing a competitive art game seeking, instead of self-knowledge and expression, the distractions of fame and fortune.
***
As we descend to the coast of the English Channel at Etretat, the Manneporte comes into view. I’ve only seen this hollowed out cliff in images painted by Monet. It’s one of those places he painted again and again. He almost drowned there. Here’s an account from a letter Claude wrote to Alice, his second wife, the words of a determined artist:
I was hard at work beneath the cliff, well sheltered from the wind, in the spot which you visited with me; convinced that the tide was drawing out I took no notice of the waves which came and fell a few feet away from me. In short, absorbed as I was, I didn’t see a huge wave coming; it threw me against the cliff and I was tossed about in its wake along with all my materials!
My immediate thought was that I was done for, as the water dragged me down, but in the end I managed to clamber out on all fours, but Lord, what a state I was in! My boots, my thick stockings and my coat were soaked through; the palette which I had kept a grip on had been knocked over my face and my beard was covered in blue, yellow etc. But anyway, now the excitement is passed and no harm’s done, the worst of it was that I lost my painting which was very soon broken up, along with my easel, bag etc. Impossible to fish anything out. Besides, everything was torn to shreds by the sea, that ‘old hag’ as your sister calls her.
Anyway, I was lucky to escape, but how I raged when I found once I’d changed that I couldn’t work, and when it dawned on me that the painting which I had been counting on was done for, I was furious. Immediately I set about telegraphing Troisgros to send me what’s missing and an easel will be ready for tomorrow . . .
He apparently did return the next day and painted "Waves at Manneport" pictured below. Monet’s paintings, however, have not prepared me for the stark beauty of this seascape, lit as it is now with a silvery late afternoon light. It is very beautiful. Passion. Determination. Authenticity. Audacity when called for. Courage always …. I now invoke for myself and my art these qualities I know I’ve already demonstrated in other parts of my life. I have the better part of three days, fresh sea air and no other agenda but to contemplate and to practice doing my art. May my expression be clear and full.

Leave a Comment